Paul Weller’s Children Win Lawsuit Over Pictures
Lawyers for the former front man of The Jam and his family sued Associated Newspapers over images of daughter Dylan and twin sons John Paul and Bowie that appeared on its MailOnline site.
Dylan was 16 and the twins 10 months old when the pictures, taken during a shopping trip in Santa Monica, were published in 2012.Judge James Dingemans ruled that although publishing the pictures was legal in California, they “were published in circumstances where Dylan, Bowie and John Paul had a reasonable expectation of privacy” – a status protected in British human rights law.
He awarded a total of 10,000 pounds ($17,000) to the children.
Paul Weller told the High Court in London that the photographer was asked to stop but persisted, “taking photos of a very frightened 16-year-old holding her baby brother.”
“What kind of person is that anyway?” he said.
MailOnline said it was “deeply disturbed” by the judgment and would appeal.
It said it was in competition with U.S-based websites protected by the First Amendment, and called the privacy ruling “a worrying development in our law, as it has conferred unfettered image rights on all the children.”