Settlement Reached Ensuring The Future Of Forest Hills Stadium Through 2040

Forest Hills Gardens Corporation (FHGC), West Side Tennis Club (WSTC) and Tiebreaker Productions, LLC (operator of Forest Hills Stadium) announced an agreement that resolves all pending litigation among the parties and sets a collaborative path forward for the century-old Queens, New York, institutions.
Under the agreement, the stadium will continue to put on shows for years to come, with significant funds directed back into the neighborhood – a portion of which is dedicated to the preservation and beautification of Forest Hills Gardens.
The stadium has faced a series of legal disputes over its outdoor concerts primarily involving neighborhood noise, zoning restrictions and whether the venue’s seasonal concert business is consistent with the residential character of the surrounding community.
Residents raised concerns about amplified music, late-night performances, traffic and the impact of large crowds, while Tiebreaker has sought to preserve the stadium as a major live-music destination.
In June 2026, a New York appellate court allowed the FHGC’s nuisance claims to proceed, while dismissing a separate lawsuit brought by Concerned Citizens of Forest Hills. The court also rejected the zoning argument in the FHGC case.
FHGC sued New York City, arguing that authorities improperly closed private neighborhood streets to accommodate concert crowds. The dispute was settled in March 2026, with the city agreeing to pay $150,000 and improve coordination with residents over police patrols.
The litigation didn’t establish a blanket ban on concerts at Forest Hills Stadium, but the surviving nuisance claims left the venue facing continued legal scrutiny over noise levels and the impact of concerts on residents. The new agreement ends pending litigation, establishes an operational framework through 2040, invests in the neighborhood and reinforces community safeguards.
The agreement establishes an initial term of seven years, with renewal options up to an additional seven years. The stadium may host up to 28 concerts per season during the initial term (up to 29 during renewal terms). All performances remain subject to strict operating standards, including a curfew for amplified sound and real-time audio monitoring aligned with City guidelines.
Tiebreaker will provide substantial payments to FHGC, including per-show payments that support the corporation, together with a one-time upfront payment, a portion of which is dedicated to restoration and beautification projects.
Under NYPD guidance, concert attendees will utilize designated routes to minimize disruption to residential corridors. The venue will continue to coordinate with NYPD in addition to deploying its own security personnel and post-show sanitation teams. The venue will also work with a community ombudsman to address resident needs in real time. Pickup zones outside of Forest Hills Gardens will be designated and coordinated with Rideshare providers.
The agreement provides for the voluntary end of all pending lawsuits between the parties, establishing a streamlined dispute-resolution process overseen by a designated Special Referee to ensure smooth ongoing collaboration.

A statement from Tiebreaker Productions: “Forest Hills Stadium’s commitment to the neighborhood of Forest Hills Gardens, the borough of Queens, and the entirety of New York City informs everything we do. First and foremost, we strive to be a good neighbor by hosting unique music and cultural events that create a positive economic impact, all while serving the neighborhood’s ethos through partnerships, local sponsorships, and sharing the use of our physical space for fundraisers and children’s events. The Club, the Gardens, and the stadium are each more than a century old and, together, share a deep interest in stewarding and protecting these precious pieces of New York City history; to maintain what came before us, to enhance our relationship with the current community, and to ensure the future of these important entities. This agreement preserves the stadium’s future and directly supports the neighborhood we are so lucky to call home. The Tiebreaker team also appreciates the enduring support and efforts by our Borough President Donovan Richards.”
From the West Side Tennis Club Board of Governors: “This agreement is an important step forward for The West Side Tennis Club and our neighbors. For more than a century, the Club has been part of the fabric of Forest Hills, bringing generations of members together through tennis and welcoming visitors from around the world to the stadium for historic moments in sport and music. Reaching this resolution took patience and constructive dialogue from all sides. We are grateful to our members as well as the Forest Hills community for their patience and engagement throughout this process. We look forward to building on this work in support of our membership the stadium’s continued success, and the benefit of the neighborhood we are proud to call home.”
From the Forest Hills Gardens Corporation Board of Directors: “For the first time in years, the Forest Hills Gardens community has clear, enforceable protections for how the stadium operates – a firm limit on the number of shows, a strict curfew, fireworks only with neighborhood approval, and meaningful financial payments. We are very happy that we were able to reach a settlement. With the divisiveness of the lawsuits now behind us, we look forward to building a constructive working relationship with the Stadium and are proud to usher in this new chapter for our community.”
The organizations acknowledged the involvement and support of city agencies, local leadership and community stakeholders in reaching the agreement. Three entities were singled out for special thanks including New York Police Department Commissioner Jessica Tisch and the leadership and officers of the 112th Precinct, who have been instrumental in managing event operations, traffic safety and community coordination; the Metropolitan Transit Authority for moving people in and out of the stadium; and the Forest Hills community for their patience, active civic engagement and commitment to the neighborhood.
Daily Pulse
Subscribe