The concert, which features DJs, aerial performances, video screens and cannons that blast paint into the crowd, is apparently sold out. The men each paid $125 for a ticket to the Pier 94 show that the seller claimed was from the Ticketfly website, according to the Cliffview Pilot.

“Only when the residents contacted Ticketfly did they learn that both were fraudulent” and had been printed for a Dayglow concert at NYC’s Hammerstein Ballroom a year ago, a police sergeant told the paper.